It’s still Trader Joe’s. (Anticlimactic, no?) There aren’t that many brands of recycled paper tissue available — NRDC has a listing (click on Facial Tissue), although I think it’s somewhat out of date since it says that Trader Joe’s is 10-25% post consumer content whereas the current box I am using says it is 80%. But you’ll notice most of them are Marcal, and dude, TJ’s is better than Marcal — I have reconfirmed this, and have a red nose to show for it. If I remember correctly, it’s better than Seventh Generation too — been a while though. Also, I like the box.
So for now, if you don’t want to contribute to two trees per year’s worth of tissue (average American usage?), plus you want to use recycled paper products (’cause what’s the point of recycling paper if no one wants the resultant products?) then I am recommending Trader Joe’s. But let me know if you find something better, because it’s not super soft with aloe or whatever. I should look into handkerchiefs — one of these days.